Maternal Mortality at Federal Medical Centre Yola, Adamawa State: A Five???Year Review
- *Corresponding Author:
- Pasura Subbaiah Sujan Ganapathy
Centre for Vrikshayurveda, A Division of Centre for Advanced Studies in Biosciences, Jain University, Chamrajpet- 560019, Karnataka, India.
E-mail: [email protected]
Citation: Bukar M, Kunmanda V, Moruppa JY, Ehalaiye B, Takai UI, Ndonya DN. Maternal mortality at federal medical centre Yola, Adamawa State: A five-year review. Ann Med Health Sci Res 2013;3:568-71.
Background: The North Eastern region of Nigeria has one of the highest maternal mortality ratios (MMRs) in the world, and most of these deaths are preventable. Culture, religion and customs that prevent access to care contribute immensely to these deaths. Aim: To review and document the MMR. Materials and Methods: This was a retrospective study of all maternal deaths recorded at the Federal Medical Centre Yola (FMCY). The case notes of all cases of maternal deaths from January 2007 to December 2011 were retrieved and relevant data obtained and analyzed. The age, parity, literacy level, booking status, causes of maternal deaths, were analysed. Data were presented in tables and percentages, using SPSS version 16(Chicago, USA 2006). Results: There were 54 maternal deaths among the 8497 deliveries, giving an overall MMR of 636 per 100,000 deliveries. Thirty three folders (33) folders were retrieved and 28 had complete information for analysis. The mean (SD) age and parity were 28.2 (6.2) and 3.4 (2.0), respectively. Most deaths (9/28; 32.1%) were in the age group of 20- 24 years. Multiparae (14/28; 50%) constituted the largest parity group. Majority (16/28; 57.1) were non-literates, 16/28 (57.1%) were of Hausa/Fulani extraction and 12/28 (42.9%) were unbooked. The leading causes of maternal mortality were preeclampsia/eclampsia (9/28; 32.1%), obstetric hemorrhage (8/28; 28.6%) and severe anemia (3/28; 10.7%). All those who died of preeclampsia/eclampsia were Hausa/Fulani. Most (14/28; 50%) deaths occurred within 24 h of admission. Majority of the deaths were Muslims (χ2 = 15.108, P = <0.001). Ethnicity had no significant influence on maternal death (χ2 = 15.550, P = 0.21). Conclusion: In conclusion, the MMR in FMCY is higher than the national average. The fact that most deaths occurred within 24 h of admission suggests that many of the patients delayed reaching the referring center for a variety of reasons. Preventive measures should focus on this delay, which is usually beyond the reach of the hospital. Measures to reduce preventable hospital deaths should also be put in place.
Eclampsia, Maternal deaths, Maternal mortality, Nigeria, Preeclampsia, Yola
The high maternal mortality indices in sub-Saharan Africa is well known. Unfortunately, the effort of the global community to address the problem of maternal mortality through the Millennium Development Goals (MDGs) seems unattainable in sub-Saharan Africa. In 1986, the World Health Organization (WHO) estimated that there were over 500,000 maternal deaths annually, with about 99% occurring in developing countries. By 2008, the number dropped to 358,000, but, regrettably, developing countries still contributed 99% of these deaths that are mostly preventable. Maternal mortality in Nigeria is among the worst in the world. Regrettably, Nigeria’s maternal mortality ratio (MMR) is comparable to countries like Liberia, Somalia and Rwanda, but lags far behind its contemporaries in the 60s (like Malaysia and Singapore, and other oil-producing countries like Kuwait, Qatar, Saudi Arabia and Iran). Globally, the high maternal mortality is not restricted to geographical location as African– American women have a higher maternal mortality rate than white Americans. Similarly, immigrants in Germany and Netherlands have higher maternal mortality rates than natives. Although regional variation in maternal mortality exist in Nigeria, the North East has one of the worst indices in Nigeria. The average MMR for Nigeria is 545/100,000 live births, while that of Borno state in North Eastern Nigeria is 1549/100,000 live births.
This review is the first audit of maternal mortality at a relatively new Federal Medical Centre in North eastern Nigeria (Federal Medical Centre Yola [FMCY]). This will serve as a benchmark for future periodical updates of maternal mortality and also record the MMR for comparisons with other institutions in Nigeria. The leading causes found in this study could help policy makers in designing policies and programmes for reduction of maternal mortality in the host community.
Materials and Methods
All maternal deaths that were recorded in the FMCY from January 2007 to December 2011 were reviewed. Information was obtained from the central records library, labor ward, gynecology ward and operation theater. The study population were patients who delivered at the FMCY and those who had miscarriages/ ectopic pregnancies or those transferred from outside the hospital. Excluded from the analysis were patients whose folders could not be traced and those with incomplete information. Thirty-three of the 54 folders were retrieved, giving a retrieval rate of 61%. Five of the 33 folders had incomplete information and, therefore, were excluded. Twenty-eight cases were therefore fully analyzed for the study. Information retrieved from the cases were age, place of residence, parity, educational status, ethnicity, religion, booking status, causes of death, duration of hospital stay before death and duration of symptoms before presentation. When there is more than one cause of death, priority was given to the primary obstetric cause as judged by the available information on patients’ case notes as reviewed by the authors. Findings were recorded on a pre-formed format sheet designed for the study and data were coded and transferred into an IBM-compatible PC and analyzed using SPSS statistical package version 16 (Chicago IL, USA). Frequency and descriptive statistics were computed. MMR was calculated by dividing maternal death by the total number of deliveries recorded within the same period multiplied by 100,000. The results are presented by simple statistical tables. P value < 0.05 was considered significant. Ethical approval was obtained from the management of the Federal Medical centre Yola before the commencement of the study.
Between January 2007 and December 2011, there were 54 maternal deaths among the 8497 deliveries, giving an overall MMR of 636 per 100,000 deliveries. Thirty three folders (33) folders were retrieved and 28 had complete information for analysis.
Table 1 shows the socio-demographic characteristics of the patients studied. The age range was 19-39 years, and the mean (SD) age was 28.2 (6.2) years. The highest maternal mortality occurred in the 20-24 year age group (9/28; 32.1%). Multiparae (14/28; 50%) constituted the largest parity group. Majority, (16/28; 57.1) were non-literates, 16/28 (57.1%) were of Hausa/Fulani extraction and 12/28 (42.9%) were unbooked. More than two-thirds (71.4%) of deaths were Muslims.
|Booked at FMCY||7||25.0|
Table 1: Sociodemographic characteristics (n=28)
Medical causes of maternal mortality are detailed in Table 2. Direct and indirect causes were seen in 82% and 18%, respectively. The leading causes of maternal mortality were preeclampsia/ eclampsia (9/28; 32.1%), obstetric hemorrhage (8/28; 28.6%) and severe anemia (3/28; 10.7%). All those who died of preeclampsia/ eclampsia were of Hausa/Fulani ethnic group.
|Cause of death||Number||Percentage|
Table 2: Medical causes of maternal mortality 2007-2011 (N=28)
Table 3 shows the annual MMRs. The highest ratio of 852 per 100,000 was recorded in 2009.
|Year||Total birth||Total death||MMR/100,000|
Table 3: Annual maternal mortality ratio
Half of the cases died within 24 h of presentation, while symptoms lasted for less than 24 h in 10/28 (35.7%) before presentation, as depicted in Table 4.
|Duration of hospital stay||Frequency||Percentage|
|24 h to 1 week||11||39.3|
|Duration of symptoms before presentation|
|24 h to 1 week||8||28.6|
Table 4: Duration of hospital stay and symptoms before maternal death
Majority of the deaths were Muslims (?2 = 15.108, P = < 0.001). Ethnicity had no significant influence on maternal death (?2 = 15.550, P = 0.21).
The high MMR in this study is in keeping with similar reviews in the North Eastern region of Nigeria.[8,9] This high MMR is a reflection of the low status of women and the poor economic indices of the region, coupled with long-standing cultural impediments to reproductive health.
Previous studies revealed that maternal mortality is high at extremes of reproductive life.[10,11] In contrast, our study has shown a low MMR in those less than 20 years. The lowest age in our study was 19 years, and she was the only patient in the age group of 15-19 years. This is probably because most of the women reside in urban areas, where early marriage is no longer in vogue. A previous unrelated study from the same center revealed that among antenatal clinic attendees, only 3.1% were teenagers. Most of the deaths occurred in women in the age of 20-24 years, which may be a reflection of the large number of women in this age group.
The Fulani ethnic group contributed the highest number. Although the Fulani group is the major ethnic group in Yola, some cultural factors like “pulaku” (stoicism) may prevent a girl from telling anyone about her pregnancy or asking any question about childbirth. They are expected to be shy or modest, and exhibit stoicism during labor and delivery. Serious complications could therefore be concealed by this misplaced stoicism, leading to maternal mortality.
It is universally accepted that non-attendance of antenatal care (ANC) is associated with high maternal mortality. Twenty-five percent each of our cases booked at the FMCY and elsewhere, leaving 42.9% as unbooked, with 7.1% whose booking status was not stated. This finding might suggest that booking alone may not prevent maternal mortality and that the emphasis should be more on the quality of care given. The number of women who had not received ANC in our study was 42.9%. This is lower than 78.9% reported from Maiduguri. Paradoxically, the MMR in that study was lower (430/100,000) when compared with our findings of 636/100,000. This may suggest the effects of confounders. It is an established fact that maternal mortality is highest among the uneducated. This has been collaborated by our study, where 57.1% were non-literate.
The leading cause of death in our study was preeclampsia/ eclampsia, 32.1%. This is similar to previous reports from Maiduguri,[8,9,11] and may be a reflection of the poor utilization of ANC services as all those who died of preeclampsia/eclapmsia had not had ANC. In addition, all were Hausa/Fulani and Muslims.
Obstetric hemorrhage is the leading cause of maternal mortality worldwide, and even in Nigeria. In this study, it was the second leading cause of maternal mortality, with Post Partum Haemorrhage (PPH) contributing 75% of the cases. This is in agreement with previous reports that showed PPH as being a more common cause of death than Antepartum Haemorrhage (APH).[11,14,15] Both deaths from APH were a result of abruptio placentae. Five (62.5%) of the eight that died of obstetric hemorrhage were booked at the FMCY. The poor blood banking services in the center might have contributed significantly to these deaths. Upgrading the blood banking facility and rapid response to emergencies may help reduce deaths from obstetric hemorrhage.
Severe anemia is no longer common, but was the third leading cause of death in our study. Those who register for ANC early and comply with hematinics are unlikely to die from complications of anemia in pregnancy. Measures to address anemia in pregnancy were documented in a previous study.
The contribution of puerperal sepsis of 7.1% in our study is in sharp contrast from a previous study in Maiduguri, where puerperal sepsis was the second leading cause of maternal mortality, and contributed 26.3%. The large number of unbooked cases and delay in presentation in that study may explain the high contribution of puerperal sepsis.
In this study, 82% were direct while 18% were indirect medical causes of maternal mortality. HIV, anesthetic deaths and Diabetic ketoacidosis (DKA) were the indirect causes of maternal mortality. HIV contributed 7.1% which is comparable to 5.2% in a previous study. HIV is becoming an important indirect cause of maternal mortality in Nigeria. The need for trained anesthestists and retraining of those on the ground is a sure way of avoidable anesthetic accident recorded in this study. The patients who died of anesthetic complications were booked with FMCY, one came for elective caesarean section and the other was diagnosed with placenta praevia when she came for ANC. Both had general anesthesia. These deaths might have been averted if regional anesthesia was used.
Obstructed labor is one of the leading causes of maternal mortality in developing countries.[8,17,18] Obstructed labor contributed 3.6% to maternal mortality is our study. This agrees with previous studies.[8,11,17,18]
Our study has some limitations. (1) Only a fraction of women delivered at the FMCY; therefore, the MMR of FMCY is not a true reflection of maternal deaths in Adamawa state. (2) The poor retrieval rate of 61% in a relatively new institution is a source of concern as unknown bias in estimates of the ratio may be considerable. (3) Among the folders retrieved, five had incomplete information for analysis. (4) MMRs generally are underestimated in developing countries, as many deliveries take place outside health facilities, and our study is no exception.
The strength of our study lies in the fact that we now have a MMR for FMCY that we can compare with other institutions. This comparison will gauge how well or otherwise our maternity services are compared with similar institutions. Future audits of maternal deaths will use our findings as a benchmark to determine the progress of policies in reduction of maternal deaths in the FMCY and the host community. The common causes of maternal deaths identified with some contributing factors, although indirectly, will direct effort at maternal mortality reduction toward the leading causes in this hospital and environs.
In conclusion, MMR in FMCY is above the national average of 545/100,000. The high number of deaths among the booked and booked elsewhere is worrisome. Quality assurance will help identify substandard care with subsequent improvement in the poor maternal mortality indices.
- Liang J, Dai L, Zhu J. Preventable maternal mortality: Geographic/rural-urban differences and associated factors from the population-based maternal mortality surveillance system in China. BMC Public Health 2011;11:243-55.
- Prata N, Passano P, Potts M. Where there are (few) skilled birth attendants. J Health Popul Nutr 2011;29:81-91.
- Kilpattrick SJ, Crabtree KE, Kemp A, Geller S. Preventability of maternal deaths: Comparison between Zambian and American referral hospital. Obstet Gynecol 2002;100:321-6.
- WHO, UNICEF, UNFPA Maternal mortality in 2000. Estimates developed by UNICEF, WHO, UNFPA. Geneva, Switzerland: World Health Organization; 2004.
- Lang CT, King JC. Maternal mortality in the United States. Best Pract Res Clin Obstet Gynaecol 2008;22:517-31.
- Razum O, Jahn A, Blettner M, Reitmaier P. Trends in maternal mortality ratio among women of German and non-German nationality in West Germany, 1980-1996. Int J Epidemiol 1999;26:919-24.
- National Population Commission (NPC) [Nigeria] and Macro. Nigerian Demographic and Health Survey 2008. Abuja, Nigeria: National Population Commission and ICF Macro; 2009.
- Chama C. Status of emergency obstetric services in six states of Nigeria (Borno state). A need assessment report: Borno State, Nigeria: Society of Gynaecology and Obstetrics of Nigeria (SOGON); 2004. p. 8-15.
- Chama C, Mairiga A, Geidam A, Bako B. An assessment of policies and programs for reducing maternal mortality in Borno state, Nigeria. Afr J Reprod Health 2010;14:49-54.
- Harrison KA. Safe motherhood. Guest Lecture at the annual general conference of the Nigeria Medical Association, Eko Le Meridien Hotel. Victoria Island, Lagos; 1990.
- Audu BM, Takai UI, Bukar M. Trends in maternal mortality at University of Maiduguri Teaching Hospital, Maiduguri,Nigeria-A five year review. Nig Med J 2010;51:147-51.
- Bukar M, Kwari DY, Moruppa JY, Ndonya DN. Anaesthesia for caesarean delivery: Choice of technique among antenatal attendees in North-eastern Nigeria. J Obstet Gynaecol 2010;30:822-5.
- El-Nafaty AU. Annual report on maternal mortality project in Borno State. Submitted to the John D and Catherine T Mac Arthur Foundation; 1997.
- DHSS report on confidential enquiries into maternal deaths in the United Kingdom. 1988-1990. London: HMSO; 1994. p. 2.
- Briggs ND. Maternal mortality in the booked and unbooked in University of Port Harcourt Teaching Hospital experience. Trop J Obstet Gynaecol 1988;1:26-9.
- Bukar M, Audu BM, Yahaya UR, Melah GS, Anaemia in pregnancy at booking in Gombe, North-eastern Nigeria. J Obstet Gynaecol 2008;28:775-8.
- Chukwudebelu WO. Preventing maternal mortality in developing countries. In: Okonofua F, Odunsi K, editors. Contemporary Obstetrics and Gynaecology for developing countries. 1st ed. Benin City: Women’s Health and Action Research Centre; 2003. p. 644-57.
- Umeora UO, Ejikeme BN, Egwuatu VE. Contribution of ruptured uterus to maternal mortality in rural south eastern Nigeria. Trop J Obstet Gynaecol 2005;22:184-8.