Nigerian Dental Technology Students and Human Immunodeficiency Virus Infection: Knowledge, Misconceptions and Willingness to Care
- *Corresponding Author:
- Dr. Clement Azodo
Department of Periodontics, New Dental Complex, University of Benin Teaching Hospital, P.M.B. 1111 Ugbowo, Benin City, Edo State 300001, Nigeria.
E-mail: [email protected]
Citation: Azodo CC, Omili MA, Akeredolu PA. Nigerian dental technology students and human immunodeficiency virus infection: Knowledge, misconceptions and willingness to care. Ann Med Health Sci Res 2014;4:330-5.
Background: The rehabilitative dental care is important for maintaining adequate nutrition, guarding against wasting syndrome and malnutrition among human immunodeficiency virus (HIV)âinfected individuals. Aim: The aim of this study is to determine the Nigerian dental technology students’ knowledge and misconceptions about HIV infection and their willingness to care for HIVâinfected patients. Subjects and Methods: This descriptive cross-sectional study of dental technology students of Federal School of Dental Therapy and Technology Enugu, Nigeria was conducted in 2010. Data was subjected to descriptive, nonâparametric and parametric statistics using the statistical package for the social sciences (SPSS) version 17.0 (Chicago Illinois, USA). P < 0.05 was considered significant. Results: The knowledge about the mode of HIV transmission and prevention among the respondents was high with some misconceptions. Specifically, the misconceptions about HIV transmission through a mosquito bite (P = 0.02) and shaking of hands (P = 0.03) were higher among respondents in the higher class than those in lower class. However, 10.6% (21/198), 6.1% (12/198) and 4.0% (8/198) of the respondents erroneous described HIV as harmless, selfâlimitation and antibiotics responsive infection respectively. Of the respondents, 78.8% (156/198) and 83.3% (165/198) of them expressed willingness to care for HIVâinfected patients and expressed need for training in the clinical care of HIVâinfected patients respectively. Overall, the respondents opined that the dental therapists are the most suitable dental professional to pass HIVârelated information to patients in the dental setting ahead of dentists and dental surgery assistants. Conclusion: The expressed willingness to care for HIVâinfected patients, knowledge about the mode of HIV transmission and prevention among the respondents were high with existent misconceptions. There were no significant differences in the knowledge about HIV infection and willingness to care for HIVâinfected patients among respondents in the lower class and those in upper class.
Care, Dental technology students, Human immunodeficiency virus-infected patients, Knowledge, Misconceptions, Willingness
There has been a dramatic increase in the number of people infected with human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) in Nigeria and globally, since the virus discovery and identification in 1983. Owing to the advent, availability and accessibility to highly active antiretroviral therapy, the systemic health, quality-of-life and above all the life expectancy of HIV-infected individuals has dramatically increased.[1-3] These have also led to the consequent increase in number of HIV-infected individuals seeking dental care. This dental care demands are in the form of routine dental care, relief from the discomfort and disability associated with concomitant oral lesions and rehabilitative dental care. The receipt of rehabilitative dental care among HIV-infected patients is on the increase with favorable prognosis.[4-7] The rehabilitative dental care in the form of dentures, crown and bridges and implants, are important in maintaining adequate nutrition and guarding against wasting syndrome and malnutrition, which are fairly common and serious problems among HIV-infected individuals.[8,9] The restoration of speech, appearance and self-esteem that may have been affected by tooth loss among HIV-infected individuals is also known to be achieved through the provision of dentures, bridges and implants.
Dental technologists are non-clinical dental auxiliaries involved in fabrication of oral prosthesis such as dentures, bridges, removable orthodontic appliances and obturators. The Higher National Diploma in dental technology is a 4 year full time training course, which qualifies an individual as a dental technologist. It is expected that dental technology students as future dental professionals are better prepared to provide the quality dental care for the HIV-infected Nigerian.
The knowledge of HIV/acquired immunodeficiency syndrome (AIDS) is crucial for dental professionals because of the increasing prevalence of the infection and also because of the significant role, it plays in preventing cross infection while providing care for HIV-infected patients both diagnosed and undiagnosed.
Studies on dental technologists’ knowledge, attitude and willingness to care for HIV-infected patients appear few in the literature when compared to other dental professionals. The objective of the study was to assess the Nigerian dental technology students’ knowledge and misconception about HIV infection and willingness to care for HIV-infected patients.
Subjects and Methods
After obtaining the necessary ethical approval and also permission from the school authority, this descriptive cross-sectional study was conducted among the 1st-4th year dental technology students of Federal School of Dental Therapy and Technology Enugu, Nigeria. The conduct of this research was consistent with the Declaration of Helsinki on Ethical Principles forl Research Involving Human Subjects. The calculated minimum sample for this study using Cochran’s formula (N = Z2Pq/d2) for epidemiological studies was 171.
N = calculated minimum sample size, Z = the standard normal deviate set at 1.96 corresponding to 95% confidence level, P = the prevalence rate, which is 0.886 (88.6%) of dental nursing students who expressed willingness to care for HIV-infected patients, q = 1.0-p, d = degree of accuracy desired (error margin) = 5% = 0.05. However, all the dental technology students of the school were included because of the small size of the study population (413 students) and the lack of baseline data on knowledge, attitude and willingness to care for HIV-infected patients among this group of dental professionals in Nigeria. The administrative record of the Department of Dental Technology showed that lower class had 314 students (Year I = 107 students and Year II = 107 students) while the higher class had 99 students (Year III = 56 students and Year IV = 43 students). However, the students who were absent for any reason during the day of the study were excluded from the study. The tool of data collection was a self-developed questionnaire, which was standardized by pretesting on dental technician students undergoing external posting in University of Benin Teaching Hospital. This self-administered questionnaire was used to obtain information on demography (age, gender and year), general knowledge about modes of transmission and prevention of HIV, feelings and willingness to care for HIV patients, the perceived role of dental technologists in the dissemination of HIV-related information, willingness to be involved in the dissemination of HIV-related information to dental patients and the public and the most suitable dental professional to pass HIV-related information in the dental clinic. The response for questions that assessed general knowledge about modes of transmission and prevention of HIV were yes, no and I don’t know. Using standard knowledge on HIV, the responses were categorized as correct knowledge and incorrect\ no knowledge. The questionnaires were distributed during a normal class session and collected at the end of the same day. Participation in this research was voluntary and no incentive was offered. Informed consent was obtained from participants after being informed of the objective of the study, assured of the confidentiality of reported information and anonymity of the questionnaire. Data analysis was performed using the Statistical Package for Social Science (SPSS version 17.0, Chicago, IL, USA) and test of significance was done with Chi-square statistics, Fisher’s exact test and independent t-test where indicated. For the purpose of analysis, the 1st and 2nd year students were categorized as those in the lower class while the 3rd and 4th year students were categorized as those in the higher class. In the assessment of overall knowledge about HIV transmission and prevention, correct knowledge was scored as 1 while incorrect/no knowledge was scored as 0 and comparison of average score using independent t-test.
A total of 260 questionnaires were distributed with 180 and 80 questionnaires distributed in the lower class and higher class respectively. Of the 260 questionnaires distributed, 198 questionnaires were returned filled giving an overall retrieval rate of 76.2% (198/260). The retrieval rate for the respondents in lower class was 81.7% (147/180) while that for the higher class was 63.8% (51/80). The majorities of the respondents were females and aged 20-23 years. The proportion of age groups are different between the upper and the class (P = 0.04) [Table 1]. The knowledge about the mode of HIV transmission and prevention among the respondents was high with some misconceptions. The misconceptions about transmission of HIV were highest for blood donation followed by mosquito bite and sharing of cups and plates. Overall, the HIV transmission and prevention mean knowledge score (standard deviation) was not significantly varied between respondents in the lower class 8.04 (0.12) and those in the higher class 7.57 (0.29) ( P = 0.08, 95% confidence interval = 0.04-0.99). However, the misconception about HIV transmission through a mosquito bite (P = 0.02) and shaking of hands (P = 0.03) were higher among respondents in the higher class [Table 2].
|Characteristics||Class n (%)||Total n (%)||P value|
|Total||147 (100.0)||51 (100.0)||198(100.0)|
Table 1: Demographic characteristics of the respondents
|Characteristics||Correct knowledge n (%)||Incorrect/no knowledge n (%)||P value|
|Lower class||Upper class||Total||Lower class||Upper class||Total|
|Modes of transmission|
|Sexual||141 (95.9)||46 (90.2)||187 (94.4)||6(4.1)||5(9.8)||11 (5.6)||0.12|
|Mosquito bite||128 (87.1)||37 (72.5)||165 (83.3)||19(12.9)||14(27.5)||33(16.7)||0.02|
|Intravenous needle||137 (93.2)||45 (88.2)||182 (91.9)||10 (6.8)||6 (11.8)||16 (8.1)||0.26|
|Shaking of hands||141 (96.6)||45 (88.2)||186 (94.4)||5(3.4)||6 (11.8)||11 (5.6)||0.03|
|Blood transfusion||143 (97.3)||46 (90.2)||189 (95.5)||4(2.7)||5(9.8)||9(4.5)||0.05F|
|Blood donation||120 (81.6)||35 (68.6)||155 (78.3)||27(18.4)||16(31.4)||43(21.7)||0.05|
|Sharing of cups/plates||126 (85.7)||44 (86.3)||170 (85.9)||21(14.3)||7 (13.7)||28(14.1)||0.92|
|Modes of prevention|
|Abstinence||127 (86.4)||41 (80.4)||168 (84.8)||20(13.6)||10(19.6)||30(15.2)||0.30|
|Fidelity||122 (83.0)||42 (82.4)||164 (82.8)||25(17.0)||9 (17.6)||34(17.2)||0.92|
|Condom||92 (62.6)||32 (62.7)||124 (62.6)||55(37.4)||19(37.3)||74(37.4)||0.98|
Table 2: General knowledge about HIV transmission and prevention among the respondents
About two-third 64.6% (128/198) of the respondents described HIV infection as a serious and deadly infection while 10.6% (21/198), 6.1% (12/198) and 4.0% (8/198) of the respondents erroneous described it as self-limitation infection, infection that can be effectively treated with antibiotics and harmless infection, respectively [Table 3]. The sympathetic and empathetic feelings were higher among the respondents in upper class, but disgust and indifferent feelings were higher among respondents in lower class. However, this was not statistically significant (P = 0.81) [Table 4]. About three-quarters 78.8% (156/198) of the respondents expressed willingness to care for HIV-infected patients. There was no significant association between the class of the respondents (lower class and upper class) and the expressed willingness to care for HIV-infected patients (P = 0.42) [Table 5]. The majority 83.3% (165/198) of the respondents expressed need for training on the clinical care of HIV-infected patients and this was not significantly different among respondents in those in lower class 82.3% (121/147) and higher class 86.3% (44/51) (P = 0.62) [Table 6].
|Opinion||Class n (%)||Total n (%)||P value|
|Serious and deadly infection||94(63.9)||34(66.7)||128 (64.6)||0.86F|
|Antibiotics responsive infection||10 (6.8)||2(3.9)||12 (6.1)|
|Self-limitation infection||15(10.2)||6 (11.8)||21(10.6)|
|Not sure||16(10.9)||6 (11.8)||22(11.1)|
|Total||147 (100.0)||51 (100.0)||198(100.0)|
Table 3: The descriptor of HIV infection among the respondents
|Feelings||Class n (%)||Total n (%)||P value|
|Total||147 (100.0)||51 (100.0)||198(100.0)|
Table 4: Respondent feelings towards HIV-infected patients
|Willingness||Class n (%)||Totaln (%)||P value|
|Total||147 (100.0)||51 (100.0)||198 (100.0)|
Table 5: Respondents’ willingness to care for HIV-infected patients
|Needs||Class n (%)||Total n (%)||P value|
|Total||147 (100.0)||51 (100.0)||198 (100.0)|
Table 6: Training needs on care for HIV-infected patients among the respondents
Respondents that expressed unwillingness to care for HIV-infected patients indicated higher training need on care for HIV-infected patients than those respondents that expressed willingness to care HIV-infected patients. However, this was not statistically significant (P = 0.50) [Table 7].
|Training||Willingness n (%)||Totaln (%)||P value|
|Yes||132(84.6)||24 (75.0)||9 (90.0)||165(83.3)||0.50F|
|No||15(9.6)||4(12.5)||1 (10.0)||20 (10.1)|
|Unsure||9 (5.8)||4(12.5)||0 (0.0)||13(6.6)|
|Total||156 (100.0)||32(100.0)||10 (100.0)||198 (100.0)|
Table 7: Willingness to care versus training needs on care for HIV-infected patients among the respondents
Three-quarters 75.3% (149/198) of the respondents asserted that the dental technologists have a role of in educating the general public about HIV among the respondents. This was not significantly varied among the respondents in lower class 74.1% (109/147) and higher class 40 (78.4%) (P = 0.80) [Table 8]. Overall, the respondents opined that the dental therapists are the most suitable dental professional to pass HIV-related information to patients in the dental setting ahead of the dentist and dental surgery assistant (P = 0.12) [Table 9]. A total of 83.2% (163/198) of the respondents expressed willingness to disseminate HIV-related information to the public. This was not significantly different among respondents in lower class 83.0% (122/198) than upper class 80.4% (41/51) (P = 0.57) [Table 10].
|Role||Class n (%)||Total n (%)||P value|
|Yes||109 (74.1)||40(78.4)||149 (75.3)||0.80|
Table 8: Perceived role of dental technologists in educating the general public about HIV among the respondents
|Dental professional||Class n (%)||Totaln (%)||P value|
|Dental surgeryassistant||33(22.4)||9 (17.6)||42(21.2)|
|Dental technologist||13 (8.8)||6 (11.8)||19 (9.6)|
|Dental record officer||6(4.1)||0(0.0)||6(3.0)|
|Total||147(100.0)||51 (100.0)||198 (100.0)|
Table 9: Respondents’ opinion of the most suitable dental professional to pass HIV-related information to patients
|Willingness||Class n (%)||Total n (%)||P value|
|Total||147 (100.0)||51 (100.0)||198(100.0)|
Table 10: Respondents’ willingness to disseminate HIV-related information to the public
The knowledge about the mode of HIV transmission and prevention among the respondents was high, but with misconceptions about the acquisition of HIV through blood donation, mosquito bite and sharing cups and plates. The misconceptions about HIV infection were also noted in the description of the infection as harmless, self-limiting and antibiotic responsive infection among the respondents. The misconceptions about the modes of HIV transmission have similarly been documented among dental nursing students, dental students and dentists in Nigeria, but are of variable degree in comparison with the finding in this study. The majority (83.2%) of the respondents expressed willingness to disseminate HIV-related information to dental patients and the general public, which may rooted on their consideration that dental technologists have roles in disseminating of HIV-related information to patients in the dental clinic and society at large. The noted misconceptions in this study indicated that the quality of HIV-related information emanating from the respondents is obviously suboptimal because they are not adequately prepared for accurate dissemination of HIV-related information to patients and the general public. It is therefore emphatic to clarify these misconceptions among the students before graduation through improved training and modification of curriculum to improve their information on HIV and infection control. The level of discrepancy in knowledge showed that there is a need for guidelines on this subject for dental technology students for them to be effectively utilized as a health educator on HIV-related issues.
In this study, the respondents generally recognized dental therapists as the most suitable dental professional to pass HIV-related information to patients in the dental setting ahead of the dentist and dental surgery assistant. The close interaction with dental therapist students who are being trained in the institution and lesser contact with other dental professionals may have broadened their knowledge about dental therapist role in primary prevention of oral disease through oral hygiene instruction, dietary counseling and scaling and polishing thereby influencing their choice.
The dental technologists are actively involved in the fabrication of oral prosthetics. These prosthetics replace missing and lost teeth and jaws with consequent improvement in nutrition and overall quality-of-life. In this study, 78.8% of the respondents expressed willingness to care for HIV-infected patients. This is lower than 93.0% reported in a national survey among Nigerian dentists and 88.6% reported among Nigerian dental nursing students signifying that non clinic-exposed dental professional students may be less likely to express willingness to treat HIV-infected patients. However, this is higher than the willingness reported among dental students (58.8-63.3%),[16,17] dentists (63.6-78.4)[13,18] and dental auxiliaries (74.7%) in Nigeria and the high level of willingness to care for HIV-infected patients in this may be attributable to the high sympathetic and empathetic feelings expressed toward HIV-infected individuals among the respondents. The willingness to care for HIV-infected patients was not significantly different among the respondents in lower class and higher class (78.9% vs. 78.4%). The high expressed needs for training on the clinical HIV care in this study signifies that well-tailored training will be the ultimate strategy for increased willingness in the future if implemented. This reaffirmed the quest for more information on HIV-related issues among dental auxiliaries as previously reported in Nigeria by Azodo et al. Similarly, the need for further education on HIV related issues like basic HIV/AIDS related issues and patient management has been reported among dental students in private and public university in Sudan. Training using HIV/AIDS information, role modeling, diffusion of training and discussions of discrimination and human rights in Nigeria has been shown to increase the willingness to treat and teach colleagues about people with HIV among health workers. This lends support to the fact that training on HIV will help in increasing the willingness of this group of dental professionals to care for HIV-infected patients. However, the finding of this study contrasted with this fact, as non-statistically significant association was found between expressed willingness to care and expressed training need on care for HIV-infected patients. This may be explained by the non-significant variation in the positive feelings toward HIV-infected patients among respondents in lower class and higher class (empathy 36 [24.5%] vs. 13 [25.5%]), (sympathetic 86 [58.5%] vs. 32 [62.7%]).
The non-significant differences in the willingness to care, training need on the clinical HIV care and willingness to disseminate HIV-related information among respondents in lower class and higher class may be explained by the non-significant different in overall knowledge about HIV transmission and prevention among the two groups. It appears therefore that the ascent dental technology education does not positively affect HIV transmission and prevention knowledge and willingness to care HIV-infected individuals. There is a need to further educate dental technology students to increase their knowledge, facilitate accurate dissemination of HIV-related information and improve the willingness to care for HIV-infected patients. The findings of this study are limited by the self-reporting nature and mode of selection of the respondents. However, the design and pretesting of the questionnaire was deemed to reduce social desirability of the responses thereby making a quality baseline data on knowledge and misconceptions about HIV infection and willingness to care for HIV-infected patients among Nigerian dental technology students.
The knowledge about the mode of HIV transmission and prevention among the respondents was high, but misconception still existed among the respondents. The expressed willingness to care for HIV-infected patients in this study was high and varied with previously reported values among dental professionals in Nigeria. However, there were no significant differences in knowledge about HIV infection and willingness to care for HIV-infected patients among respondents in lower class and those in upper class.
- King JT Jr, Justice AC, Roberts MS, Chang CC, Fusco JS, Collaboration in HIV Outcomes Research-US Program Team. Long-term HIV/AIDS survival estimation in the highly active antiretroviral therapy era. Med Decis Making 2003;23:9-20.
- Lima VD, Hogg RS, Harrigan PR, Moore D, Yip B, Wood E, et al. Continued improvement in survival among HIV-infectedindividuals with newer forms of highly active antiretroviral therapy. AIDS 2007;21:685-92.
- Fang CT, Chang YY, Hsu HM, Twu SJ, Chen KT, Lin CC, et al. Life expectancy of patients with newly-diagnosed HIVinfection in the era of highly active antiretroviral therapy. QJM 2007;100:97-105.
- Shetty K, Achong R. Dental implants in the HIV-positive patient: Case report and review of the literature. Gen Dent 2005;53:434-7.
- Strietzel FP, Rothe S, Reichart PA, Schmidt-Westhausen AM. Implant-prosthetic treatment in HIV-infected patients receiving highly active antiretroviral therapy: Report of cases. Int J Oral Maxillofac Implants 2006;21:951-6.
- Choromanska M, Waszkiel D. Prosthetic status and needs of HIV positive subjects. Adv Med Sci 2006;51 Suppl 1:106-9.
- Santo AE, Tagliaferro EP, Ambrosano GM, Meneghim MC, Pereira AC. Dental status of Portuguese HIV+ patients and related variables: A multivariate analysis. Oral Dis 2010;16:176-84.
- Süttmann U, Ockenga J, Selberg O, Hoogestraat L, Deicher H, Müller MJ. Incidence and prognostic value of malnutrition and wasting in human immunodeficiency virus-infected outpatients. J Acquir Immune Defic Syndr Hum Retrovirol 1995;8:239-46.
- Niyongabo T, Melchior JC, Henzel D, Bouchaud O, Larouzé B. Comparison of methods for assessing nutritional status in HIV-infected adults. Nutrition 1999;15:740-3.
- World Health Organization. Expert committee on auxiliary dental personnel. World Health Organ Tech Rep Ser 1959;58:3-32. Available from: http://whqlibdoc.who.int/trs/ WHO_TRS_163.pdf.
- Cochran WG. Sampling Techniques. 3rd ed. New York: John Wiley and Sons; 1977. p. 190-205.
- Azodo C, Umoh A, Ezeja E, Ukpebor M, Ehizele A. A survey of HIV-related knowledge and attitude among dental nursing students in South Western Nigeria. Benin J Postgrad Med 2007;9:1-12.
- Ajayi YO, Ajayi EO. Dental students' knowledge of human immunodeficiency virus. J Dent 2008;36:374-8.
- Utomi IL, Onajole AT, Arotiba JT. HIV/AIDS: Knowledge and attitudes of dentists in South-Western Nigeria. Niger J Health Biomed Sci 2008;7:36-41.
- Azodo CC, Ehizele AO, Umoh A, Ogbebor G. Preventing HIV transmission in Nigeria: Role of the dentists. Malays J Med Sci 2010;17:10-7.
- Azodo CC, Ehigiator O, Oboro HO, Ehizele AO, Umoh A, Ezeja EB, et al. Nigerian dental students’ willingness to treat HIV-positive patients. J Dent Educ 2010;74:446-52.
- Oboro HO, Azodo CC, Sede MA. Perception of HIV/ AIDS among preclinical dental students. J Prev Med Hyg 2010;51:164-9.
- Uti OG, Agbelusi GA, Jeboda SO. Are Nigerian dentists willing to treat patients with HIV infection? Niger Dent J 2007:15:66-70.
- Azodo CC, Ehigiator O, Ojo MA. Occupational risks and hepatitis B vaccination status of dental auxiliaries in Nigeria. Med Princ Pract 2010;19:364-6.
- Nasir EF, Astrøm AN, David J, Ali RW. HIV and AIDS related knowledge, sources of information, and reported need for further education among dental students in Sudan: A cross sectional study. BMC Public Health 2008;8:286.
- Ezedinachi EN, Ross MW, Meremiku M, Essien EJ, Edem CB, Ekure E, et al. The impact of an intervention to change health workers’ HIV/AIDS attitudes and knowledge in Nigeria: A controlled trial. Public Health 2002;116:106-12.